Into the Mountains, Into the Unknown
In this blog, we’re diving into one of the more controversial and chilling survival stories from the American frontier—the story of Alfred Packer and his ill-fated trek into the Rocky Mountains during the winter of 1874. This story is a test of endurance, impossible choices, and the unforgiving power of the wilderness. In the freezing, isolated mountains of Colorado, Packer and his expedition faced a situation no one could have predicted.
In the following chapters, we’ll look at what drove Packer and his companions into the Rockies, the harsh survival tactics used to endure the journey, and the controversial choices that sparked an infamous tale of survival. So let’s jump right in.
Chapter 1: The Call of Fortune
In the early 1870s, gold fever was spreading across the United States, and countless men set off west in search of fortune. Alfred Packer, a prospector born in Pennsylvania, was no stranger to this allure. He had already spent years prospecting across Colorado and Utah, hoping to find his riches.
But Packer wasn’t without his struggles. He had epilepsy, which often made his travels many times more challenging. Nevertheless, he joined a group of 20 other gold seekers in November 1873, bound for the Gunnison River Valley in Colorado. The journey promised adventure and, with luck, wealth. But it also promised treacherous conditions, rough terrain, and the unpredictable dangers of mountain travel in the dead of winter.
As they neared the San Juan Mountains, winter weather grew more intense. Deep snow covered the trails, temperatures plummeted, and the group quickly realised they’d underestimated the journey. With supplies dwindling, the group’s leader decided they needed to find food and shelter before pressing on, but by then, the sheer intensity of the mountain winter had locked them in a deadly embrace.
The decision to push forward or turn back would soon prove critical, especially when six members—including Alfred Packer—decided to break off from the group, convinced they could find a route through to Gunnison.
Chapter 2: Surviving the Wilderness
This smaller group of six, including Packer, faced unimaginable conditions as they pressed forward. With temperatures below freezing, the snow so deep it obscured any path, and dwindling rations, they were forced to rely on every ounce of survival knowledge they possessed.
Initially, the group rationed what food they had left, likely hoping to find game along the way. But in the frozen wilderness, the animals had gone into hiding. Days stretched into weeks, and the cold and hunger became brutal companions. They faced a crucial survival decision: whether to keep moving or conserve energy and shelter in place.
According to accounts, they scavenged for whatever they could find—bark from trees, the occasional squirrel—but even that wasn’t enough. As the snow piled higher, their bodies began to weaken from cold, hunger, and exhaustion. Facing starvation, they took the desperate step of boiling their leather belts and shoes, hoping to draw out any nutrients they could. It’s a method used in survival to extract calories from otherwise useless materials, though hardly a solution to sustain life.
Surviving in such conditions requires physical resilience, but just as crucial is the mental aspect. They needed sheer willpower to keep moving forward, pushing through the frozen terrain with minimal resources. And as their energy waned, tension and fear began to strain the group’s morale.
Then, their ordeal took an even darker turn.
Chapter 3: The Dark Choice
As weeks passed, Packer became the sole survivor of the group. According to Packer’s account, the others had succumbed one by one to hunger, cold, or injury. Faced with starvation and a deadly winter, he made a decision that would forever define his story. Packer claimed that he survived by using the bodies of his deceased companions for sustenance—a choice so unimaginable, yet one that has been documented in many cases of survival.
This is where his story becomes complicated. After eventually making it to Los Pinos Indian Agency, Packer was discovered by a group of locals, disoriented and gaunt but very much alive. Initially, he claimed that he’d survived alone after his companions had died from the elements. But as locals found the remains of his group, suspicions grew.
Packer was arrested, and over the following months, his story would change several times. He insisted his choices were acts of survival—no different from anyone else faced with starvation. But others questioned his motives and honesty. This led to accusations, theories, and a criminal trial that would haunt his legacy.
In situations of survival, people often rely on their instincts, and Packer’s instinct was to survive by any means necessary. His case was deeply divisive, raising questions of morality and ethics that still spark debate today
Chapter 4: Trial and Legacy
In 1883, nearly a decade after the events, Packer’s case went to trial. Accused of murder and cannibalism, he was sentenced to death, though he maintained that his actions were purely for survival. The public was split—some saw him as a victim of circumstance, others as a villain who’d taken advantage of his companions’ deaths.
Though his sentence was later commuted to 40 years in prison, Packer’s story left a lasting legacy, one of both survival and infamy. Historians and scholars still study his case, debating the ethics of survival decisions made under extreme conditions.
For his part, Packer never stopped defending his actions as a means to survive in a desperate situation. His story reveals not only the brutal choices some face in life-or-death circumstances but also the strength it takes to endure such trials. Ultimately, the story of Alfred Packer serves as a reminder of the extremes to which people will go when faced with starvation, isolation, and the unforgiving power of nature.
Packer in 1874
Final Thoughts: Survival and Consequence
The tale of Alfred Packer and the Rocky Mountains expedition is as haunting as it is complex. It pushes us to ask tough questions about survival: what would we be willing to do in the face of starvation? How does the instinct to survive shape our choices, and where is the line between survival and morality?
Today, we remember Packer’s story as one that challenges our understanding of endurance. The mountains he traversed were not just a physical barrier—they became a test of willpower, ethics, and humanity.
Thank you for joining me here at Barely Surviving as we delved into the chilling story of Alfred Packer. I hope this story leaves you with questions, reflections, and maybe even a bit of gratitude for the comforts we often take for granted. Until next time, stay safe, stay resilient, and remember: survival can bring out both the best and the worst in us.
Comments